Go to ...

Troubled Projects

Special Interest Group

Troubled Projects on Google+Troubled Projects on YouTubeTroubled Projects on LinkedInTroubled Projects on TumblrTroubled Projects on PinterestRSS Feed

The Relevance of Project Closeout and Evaluation in Project Management.


The very well acknowledged English phrase “final but not minimum” could not much better describe how important the project closeout period is. Remaining the incredibly final section of the project existence-cycle it is often disregarded even by significant businesses, specially when they work in multi-project environments. They are likely to soar from just one project to yet another and rush into finishing each individual project for the reason that time is urgent and means are expensive. Then projects retain failing and businesses consider no corrective actions, merely for the reason that they do not have the time to believe about what went completely wrong and what need to be preset up coming time. Lessons realized can be reviewed at project evaluations as section of the closeout period. Closure also deals with the final particulars of the project and delivers a ordinary ending for all treatments, such as the supply of the final product. This paper identifies the motives that closeout is neglected, analyzes the ideal procedures that could increase its place in the business enterprise surroundings and counsel added techniques for a entire project closeout through ongoing enhancement.

Task managers often know when to finish a projects but they overlook how to do it. They are so eager to entire a project that they barely pass up the completion indicators. “Ideally, the project ends when the project goal has been accomplished and is completely ready to hand more than to shopper” (Wellace et. al, 2004, p156). In moments of major booms and bubbles, senior administration could get the quick termination of expensive projects. A characteristic example of that is Bangkok’s more than expense in construction of sky-scrapers, the place most of them still left deserted with no finishing the final flooring thanks to great fees (Tvede, 2001, p267). Assignments closely hooked up to time can be terminated in advance of ordinary finishing position if they pass up a significant deadline, such as an invitation to tender. Kerzner (2001, p594) adds some behavioural motives for early termination such as “inadequate morale, human relations or labour efficiency”. The violent nature of early termination is also acknowledged as ‘killing a project’ for the reason that it “entails severe career and financial outcomes” (Futrel, Shafer D & Shafer L, 2002, 1078). Killing a project can be a complicated determination given that psychological concerns produce delight in an corporation and a dread of currently being seen as quitters blurs managerial selections (Heerkens, 2002, p229).


The most immediate reason that Project Closeout period is neglected is absence of means, time and spending plan. Even nevertheless most of project-primarily based businesses have a critique method formally planned, most of the moments “supplied the strain of do the job, project staff member discovered them selves currently being assigned to new projects as quickly as a recent project is completed” (Newell, 2004). Moreover, the senior administration often considers the charge of project closeout unnecessary. Sowards (2005) implies this additional charge as an energy “in preparing, holding and documenting productive post project evaluations”. He attracts a parallel amongst evaluations and investments for the reason that both of those demand a start-up expenditure but they can also pay out dividends in the long term.

Human nature avoids accountability for severe defects. Hence, customers of project groups and specially the project manager who has the total accountability, will unsurprisingly avoid such a critique of their do the job if they can. As Kerzner (2001, p110) observe, “documenting successes is uncomplicated. Documenting faults is additional troublesome for the reason that people today do not want their names hooked up to faults for dread of retribution”. Thomset (2002, p260) compares project evaluations with the ‘witch hunts’ indicating that they can be “just one of the most political and cynical of all organizational procedures the place the victims (the project manager and the staff) are blamed by senior administration”. Although he identifies top administration as the primary liable occasion for a failure, Murray (2001) counsel that the project manager “have to take supreme accountability, regardless of the components concerned”. A reasonable-minded stance on these unique viewpoints would evoke that the objective of the project critique is not to locate a scapegoat but to find out from the faults. After all, “the only correct project failures are these from which practically nothing is realized” (Kerzner, 2004, p303).


When the project is concluded, the closeout period have to be applied as planned. “A normal rule is that project closing need to consider no additional than two% of the whole energy needed for the project” (Crawford, 2002, p163). The project management literature has many unique sets of actions for the final period of the project existence cycle. Maylor (2005, p345) groups the vital things to do into a 6 phase procedure, which can vary relying on the dimension and the scope of the project:


Initial of all, the project manager have to make sure the project is a hundred% entire. Younger (2003, p256) noticed that in the closeout period “it is rather frequent to locate a variety of remarkable minimal responsibilities from early critical stages nonetheless unfinished. They are not significant and have not impeded development, nonetheless they have to be completed”. Also, some projects require continuing service and guidance even after they are concluded, such as IT projects. Although it is valuable when this need is section of the authentic statement of requirements, it is often section of the agreement closeout. Rosenau and Githens (2005, p300) counsel that “the contractor need to see continuing service and guidance as an chance and not just as an obligation” given that they can both of those find out from each individual other by exchanging thoughts.

Mooz et. al (2003, p160) defines documentation as “any textual content or pictorial information that describe project deliverables”. The significance of documentation is emphasized by Pinkerton (2003, p329) who notes that “it is very important that almost everything realized for the duration of the project, from conception through original operations, need to be captured and turn out to be an asset”. A comprehensive documentation will enable long term improvements to be built with no extraordinary energy given that all the elements of the project are penned down. Documentation is the critical for very well-arranged improve of the project owner, i.e. for a new trader that normally takes more than the project after it is concluded. Lecky-Thompson (2005, p26) can make a distinction amongst the documentation requirements of the interior and the exterior clients given that the exterior occasion generally demands the paperwork for audit purposes only. Even with the uninteresting nature of documenting historical details, the individual liable for this undertaking have to have interaction actively with his assignment.

3.Task Systems Closure
All project methods have to close down at the closeout period. This features the economical methods, i.e. all payments have to be completed to exterior suppliers or vendors and all do the job orders have to terminate (Department of Veterans Affairs, 2004, p13). “In closing project documents, the project manager need to provide documents up to day and make certain all authentic paperwork are in the project documents and at just one location” (Arora, 1995). Maylor (2005, 347) counsel that “a official see of closure need to be issued to tell other team and guidance methods that there are no additional things to do to be carried out or fees to be built”. As a consequence, unnecessary fees can be prevented by unauthorized expenditure and clients will comprehend that they can not receive added products and services at no charge.

four.Task Critiques
The project critique arrives generally arrives after all the project methods are closed. It is a bridge that connects two projects that occur just one after yet another. Project evaluations transfer not only tangible understanding such as numerical details of charge and time but also the tacit understanding which is tough to doc. ‘Know-how’ and additional important ‘know-why’ are handed on to long term projects in get to eradicate the require for project managers to ‘invent the wheel’ from scratch each time they start a new project. The reuse of current instruments and knowledge can be expanded to unique project groups of the very same corporation in get to increase project benefits (Bucero, 2005). Critiques have a holistic nature which look into the impression of the project on the surroundings as a total. Audits can also be valuable but they are targeted on the interior of the corporation. Organizing the evaluations need to involve the correct time and spot for the workshops and most important the people today that will be invited. Deciding on the proper people today for the critique will increase the price of the assembly and support the learning method whilst acquiring an objective critique not only by the staff customers but also from a neutral exterior auditor. The final result of this critique need to be a final report which will be offered to the senior administration and the project sponsor. Whitten (2003) also notices that “often just making ready a critique presentation forces a project staff to believe through and remedy many of the issues publicly exposing the state of their do the job”.

5.Disband the project staff

Ahead of reallocating the team among other means, closeout period delivers an exceptional chance to assess the energy, the dedication and the benefits of each individual staff member individually. Excess-ordinary effectiveness need to be complemented in public and symbolic benefits could be granted for innovation and creativity (Gannon, 1994). This method can be very important for staff gratification and can make improvements to dedication for long term projects (Reed, 2001). Examining a project can be in the variety of a reflective method, as illustrated in the up coming figure, the place project managers “file and critically reflect upon their have do the job with the intention of increasing their administration techniques and effectiveness” (Bathroom, 2002). It can also be utilized in problematic project groups in get to identify the roots of possible conflicts and provide them into an open up dialogue.

Ignoring the recognized position of see of disbanding the project staff as quickly as possible to avoid unnecessary overheads, Meredith and Mandel (2003, p660) imply that it truly is ideal to hold out as a great deal as you can for two primary motives. Initial it helps to decrease the aggravation that could possibly deliver a staff member’s reassignment with unfavourable prospective customers. 2nd it keeps the curiosity and the professionalism of the staff customers high as it is frequent ground that for the duration of the closing stages, some slacking is probably to surface.

six.Stakeholder gratification

PMI’s PMBoK (2004, p102) defines that “actions and things to do are vital to verify that the project has met all the sponsor, shopper and other stakeholders’ requirements”. These kinds of actions can be a final presentation of the project critique which features all the important information that need to be published to the stakeholders. This information can involve a timeline exhibiting the development of the project from the beginning until finally the finish, the milestones that have been met or missed, the issues encountered and a brief economical presentation. A very well geared up presentation which is targeted on the robust elements of the projects can protect some flaws from the stakeholders and make a failure appear like an sudden achievement.

Upcoming Actions

Even when the shopper accepts the supply of the final product or service with a official signal-off (Dvir, 2005), the closeout period need to not be observed as an energy to get rid of a project. Alternatively, the critical concern in this period is “acquiring follow-up business enterprise progress prospective from the project deliverable” (Barkley & Saylor, 2001, p214). Consequently, the project can generate precious shopper partnerships that will increase the business enterprise chances of the corporation. Remaining the final period, the project closeout performs a crucial position in sponsor gratification given that it is a frequent ground that the final impression is the just one that ultimately stays in people’s head.

Constant enhancement is a idea that we often listen to the final decade and critique workshops need to be concerned in it. The idea behind this idea is that organizations have to locate new approaches to sustain their competitive edge in get to be among the marketplace leaders. To do so, they have to have a very well-structured strategy to organizational learning which in project-primarily based businesses is materialized in the project critique. Garratt (1987 in Kempster, 2005) highlighted the significance of organizational learning indicating that “it is not a luxurious, it is how businesses find out their long term”. Linking organizational learning with Kerzner’s (2001, p111) 5 components for ongoing enhancement we can a define a structured strategy for understanding projects.

This strategy can be applied in the closeout period, with systematic evaluations for each individual of the above components. Executing so, project closure could receive the attention it deserves and be a actually powerful process for ongoing enhancement in an corporation. Ultimately, project closeout period need to be linked with PMI’s Organizational Project Management Maturity (OPM3) model the place the lessons realized from just one project are very precious to other projects of the very same program in get to achieve the maximum project management maturity top.


one.A Information to Project Management Body of Understanding, 2004, 3rd Edition, Project Management Institute, United states, p102

two.Arora M, 1995, Project management: A single phase past, Civil Engineering, sixty five, ten, [Electronic], pp 66-sixty eight

3.Barkley & Saylor, 2001, Client-Pushed Project Management, McGraw-Hill Specialist, United states, p214

four.Bucero A, 2005, Project Know-How, PM Community, May perhaps 2005 concern, [Electronic], pp twenty-22

5.Crawford K, 2002, The Strategic Project Office, Marcel Dekker, United states, p163

six.Department of Veteran Affairs, 2004, Project Management Information, Office of Information and facts and Technological know-how – United states Federal government, p13

seven.Dvir D, 2005, Transferring projects to their final users: The result of preparing and preparations for commissioning on project achievement, Global Journal of Project Management vol. 23, [Electronic], pp 257-265

eight.Futrel R, Shafer D & Shafer L, 2002, Quality Software program Project Management, Prentice Hall PTR, United states, p1078

9.Gannon, 1994, Project Management: an strategy to accomplishing matters, Records Management Quarterly, Vol. 28, Issue 3, [Electronic], pp 3-12

ten.Heerkens G, 2002, Project Management, McGraw-Hill, United states, p229

eleven.Kempster S, 2005, The Will need for Adjust, MSc in Project Management: Adjust Management module, Lancaster University, [Electronic], slide sixteen

12.Kerzner H, 2004, Sophisticated Project Management: Finest Procedures on Implementation, 2nd Edition, Wiley and Sons, p303

13.Kerzner H, 2001, Project Management – A Systems Approach to Organizing, Scheduling and Controlling, 7th Edition, John Wiley & Sons, New York, p594

14.Kerzner H, 2001, Strategic Organizing For Project Management Working with A Project Management Maturity Design, Wiley and Sons, pp one hundred ten-111

15.Lecky-Thompson G, 2005, Company Software program Project Management, Charles River Media, United states, p26

sixteen.Bathroom R, 2002, Journaling: A learning instrument for project management coaching and staff-making, Project Management Journal Dec 2002 concern, vol. 33, no. four, [Electronic], pp 61-66

seventeen.Maylor H, 2005, Project Management, 3rd Edition with CD Microsoft Project, Prentice Hall, Uk, p345

18.Mooz H, Forsberg K & Cotterman H, 2003, Speaking Project Management: The Integrated Vocabulary of Project Management and Systems Engineering, John Wiley and Sons, United states, p160

19.Murray J, 2001, Recognizing the accountability of a unsuccessful information engineering project as a shared failure, Information and facts Systems Management, Vol. 18, Issue two, [Electronic], pp twenty five-29

twenty.Newell S, 2004, Enhancing Cross-Project Studying, Engineering Management Journal, Vol. sixteen, No.one, [Electronic], pp 12-twenty

21.Organizational Project Management Maturity (OPM3): Understanding Basis, 2003, 3rd Edition, Project Management Institute, United states

22.Pinkerton J, 2003, Project Management, McGraw-Hill, p329

23.Reed B, 2001, Producing matters occur (much better) with project management, May perhaps/Jun 2001 concern, 21, 3, [Electronic], pp 42-46

24.Rosenau & Githens, 2005, Productive Project Management, 4th Edition, Wiley and Sons, United states, p300

twenty five.Sowards D, 2005, The price of post project evaluations, Contractor, fifty two, eight, [Electronic], p35

26.Thomset R, 2002, Radical Project Management, Prentice Hall PTR, United states, p260

27.Whitten N, 2003, From Good to Wonderful, PM Community, Oct 2003 concern, [Electronic]

28.Younger, 2003, The Handbook of Project Management: A Practical Information to Successful Guidelines and Strategies, 2nd Edition, Kogan Web page, Uk, p256


About Editorial Staff

The Editorial Staff are the volunteer members behing the Troubled Projects SIG publication. It is formed by top referent experts globally recognized. The Editorial Staff directs and performs quality control and assurance in all the articles published.